As most of us know, criticizing Israel is not antisemitic. Isolating Israel and only criticizing her for the same crimes that other nations commit is indeed antisemitic. Calling for Israel's demise is antisemitic. Though "jpcarlisle" is not directly calling for Israel's demise. The writing is on the wall, suggesting the right of return (which will never happen as the average Palestinian female births five kids before she is 25, which means that the Palestinians within a short period will out-breed the Israelis, vote them out, and Israel will cease to be Jewish state or even be known as Israel). You decide if it's antisemitic or not.
Original link to the comment.